When Eli Manning first donned a fake mustache and the alias “Chad Powers” in his viral 2022 ESPN+ skit, few expected the joke would eventually become a full-blown television series. However, under the creative direction of alumnus Glen Powell and Michael Waldron (“Loki”), they reimagine Manning’s alter ego into a sports comedy that feels emotionally grounded yet narratively uneven.
With the final episode airing on Oct. 28, we follow Russ Holliday (Glen Powell), a disgraced former college quarterback, who disguises himself as Chad Powers to try out for the South Georgia Catfish. From its opening episode, the show displays a noticeable step-up from the original skit. Individual scenes are cinematic and emotionally heartfelt, highlighting Waldron’s flair for storytelling. The show often puts football in the backseat, allowing relationships between characters to shine, and often focuses on the dynamic between Ricky Hudson and her father, Coach Hudson.
Powell delivers a standout comedic performance as both Chad and Russ. Powell transitions effortlessly between Chad, the awkward oddball, and Russ, the arrogant and earring-sporting disgrace. Powell’s ability to make Chad as lovable as Russ is detestable, showcasing his impressive range. Even under Chad’s prosthetic mask, audiences can see and feel his expressions clearly. Powell’s flexibility between slapstick comedy and sincerity gives the show an emotional depth, even when the writing falters.
Despite the show’s strong moments, “Chad Powers” feels rushed and incomplete, even when disregarding the season’s cliffhanger ending. Several plot-holes are dropped or glossed over, detracting from the charming show and its main character. Certain subplots, especially one involving Chad’s relationship with his gay father, tease significance and opportunity for connection but lead nowhere.
One of the show’s strengths lies in its supporting cast. Perry Mattfield’s performance as Ricky Hudson balances toughness and vulnerability as she highlights Ricky’s strained relationship with her dad and her desire to succeed in her career. The hint of romance between Ricky and both Powell’s characters adds another layer of complexity to the show, proving it’s more than a series about football. In addition, Wynn Everett’s performance as Tricia, the South Georgia Catfish’s booster trust chair, is humorous with a commanding comic presence in every scene.
“Chad Powers” constantly references the chronically online world, with mentions of DeuxMoi, cybertrucks, crypto scams and even a cameo from Haliey Welch (the Hawk Tuah girl). These references contribute to a playful and modern comedic tone, apt for a show set in 2025.
Whilst the “Chad Powers” story is flawed, it succeeds as a reinvention of the sports comedy genre. It extends beyond a football show for jocks to one that offers genuine heart. Beneath the prosthetics and viral references, “Chad Powers” charmingly explores identity, promising more comedy and charisma in its second season.
3 cybertrucks out of 5
