The quiet domesticity that Marvel fans long celebrated has been shattered by a whisper: the suggestion that actor Chris Evans may have been unfaithful to his wife, actress Alba Baptista, just weeks after the reported arrival of their first child. It is a story straight out of a Hollywood nightmare, where a private fairy tale is hijacked by the viral chaos of social media speculation.
Now, the actor known globally as Captain America has been forced onto the defensive, not against a supervillain, but against an anonymous claim originating from the deepest corners of the internet.
The epicentre of the scandal is a single, unverified rumour, but the subsequent media frenzy has raised a chilling question: Can a baseless ‘blind item’ torpedo the meticulously crafted public image of one of Hollywood’s most beloved stars?
The Blind Item Blitz: Unpacking the Chris Evans Cheating Rumours
The explosive allegations first surfaced in November 2025 through a rapid series of anonymous ‘blind items’ on platforms like TikTok and X (formerly Twitter). The original posts, shared by gossip accounts such as @celebritea.blinds, made a single, provocative claim: an unnamed ‘A-list actor from Boston’ had been observed discreetly socialising with a brunette woman at a local bar.
The key detail that immediately ignited the scandal was the timing, as the posts specifically mentioned the actor’s wife had ‘recently given birth.’ This single piece of information acted as a social media magnet, leading internet users to immediately connect the dots to Chris Evans, a Boston native who had welcomed his first child with Alba Baptista just weeks prior.
Subsequent items further fuelled the fire, alleging the actor was seen at a Back Bay establishment, a Boston bar rumoured to maintain a discrete, ‘no cameras, no questions’ policy. The rumour also suggested the same woman was adjusting her schedule to maintain secrecy.
News outlets, including Pop Rant, Bored Panda, and FandomWire, noted the overwhelming popularity of the ‘blind item’ online, yet consistently stressed that no credible evidence or verified eyewitness accounts have surfaced to corroborate the infidelity allegations.
Tara Testa: The Woman at the Centre of the Chris Evans Speculation
The crisis deepened when the online rumour mill fixated on the identity of the alleged mistress: Tara Testa. This theory, however, quickly met resistance due to Testa’s well-documented, decades-long history with Chris Evans.
Testa is reportedly a long-time friend of Evans, believed to be from the same Massachusetts area where the actor grew up. Their connection briefly entered the public consciousness in 2015 when Testa accompanied Evans to the Academy Awards.
This red-carpet appearance sparked dating rumours, which Testa publicly shut down in a televised interview. She emphatically clarified, ‘Oh no! I’m not his girlfriend’, a sentiment immediately mirrored by Evans, who described her as ‘one of my best friends on the planet from back home’, emphasising their strictly platonic connection.
The actor also confirmed the longevity of their friendship in a 2011 interview, mentioning his bulldog, Dodger, often stayed with ‘a girl named Tara—I grew up with her in Boston, and she’s lived out in L.A. for a few years. She absolutely adores him.’
This established history suggests Testa is not a new figure, but a consistently acknowledged platonic friend.
Currently, neither Evans, Baptista, nor their representatives have made any public statement regarding the claims. While some online expressed disappointment based on the unconfirmed claims, a significant portion of the public has urged restraint, criticising the unverified nature of the gossip.
The fact that the entire scandal rests on anonymous posts and a long-standing platonic friendship is the strongest argument against the sensational claims.
