“What’s your OnlyFans?”: Paulina Gretzky blasted for provocative Halloween outfit and sexualizing childhood icons on purpose
Paulina Gretzky’s Halloween costume as Jessie from Toy Story sparked immediate online debate, drawing comparisons to Kendall Jenner’s similar 2022 outfit. Critics accused Gretzky of oversexualizing a children’s character, reigniting discussions about adult interpretations of beloved icons. Supporters, however, defended it as harmless holiday fun, highlighting the ongoing tension between nostalgia and modern aesthetics. Paulina Gretzky did what most celebrity couples do on Halloween, she dressed up, shared the photos, and let social media react. But the response this year was anything but casual scroll-by fun. The daughter of NHL legend Wayne Gretzky stepped out dressed as Jessie from Toy Story, matching husband Dustin Johnson’s Woody costume.But instead of just being another themed couple look, the internet immediately began comparing her styling to Kendall Jenner’s 2022 Jessie costume, the same one that triggered a round of online controversy over whether Halloween is crossing into territory that oversexualizes characters originally designed for children. Within hours, the comparisons resurfaced, so did the backlash.
Paulina’s Jessie costume becomes another case study in how adult media culture interprets children’s characters
Paulina posted the images to Instagram with the caption “Y𝗈𝗎’𝗏𝖾 𝗀𝗈𝗍 𝖺 𝖿𝗋𝗂𝖾𝗇𝖽 𝗂𝗇 𝗆𝖾.” Her outfit, cropped top, cow-print chaps, pigtails, wasn’t radically different from Jenner’s 2022 version, which itself made headlines for being too provocative. That’s the comparison critics instantly revived: fans said it’s déjà vu.On X, commenters referenced the previous Kendall discourse — one wrote: “Toy Story isn’t a s*x icon. Unacceptable.” Another commented,“What’s your OnlyFans?” Another echoed the Kardashian-era reaction: “Didn’t we try to cancel a Kardashian for this now it’s okay?” That sentiment spread quickly, especially after DramaAlert resurfaced Jenner’s original images.
The debate isn’t only about costumes — it’s about entertainment culture and shifting boundaries
What’s interesting is not the costume itself, but the response pattern. Social media instantly reverts to moral-line-drawing: what is harmless adult cosplay, and what is sexualization of imagery designed for kids? One user’s X comment summed up the loudest opinion: “Somebody please tell me why all of these entertainers are sexualizing children’s costumes… 😡😡”Yet others defended Paulina, calling Halloween escapism, not social commentary. And in that tension, nostalgia vs. aesthetics vs. adult identity, is exactly where these celebrity look controversies now live.It’s Woody and Jessie but filtered through an internet that now debates everything.Also Read: “Show me some fu**ing emotion”: Former Maple Leafs enforcer rips Auston Matthews’ leadership amid Leafs’ shaky October
