By Marcus Moloko
Tensions have risen in the DA as Dion George’s dual citizenship and leadership come under scrutiny amid calls for his replacement.
The Democratic Alliance (DA) is facing internal turbulence following revelations about the Minister of Environment, Forestry and Fisheries Dion George’s dual citizenship and a controversial request by DA leader and Minister of Agriculture, John Steenhuisen, to have him replaced by party spokesperson Willie Aucamp.
The move has sparked debate within political circles and civil society, raising questions about governance, coalition dynamics, and the strategic direction of South Africa’s environmental leadership.
Dion George who is a US citizen and member of RSA cabinet, travelled to the UN general assembly to represent South Africa, using his US passport. pic.twitter.com/d5FnGOmheX
— Govan Whittles 🇿🇦 (@govanwhittles) November 8, 2025
Minister George confirmed in a parliamentary reply that he holds dual citizenship with South Africa and the United States, a fact that was declared during his vetting.
The disclosure has reignited concerns about transparency and loyalty, especially in a ministry tasked with navigating complex global negotiations on climate change and environmental policy.
Steenhuisen’s request to President Cyril Ramaphosa to replace George has drawn mixed reactions. Some analysts view it as a routine coalition negotiation, typical of the post-election power-sharing arrangements. Others warn that it risks undermining the president’s constitutional authority, setting a precedent where party leaders attempt to dictate executive appointments.
Political analyst Professor Mazwe Majola, speaking on Newzroom Africa, acknowledged the DA’s right to demand accountability but cautioned against premature conclusions.
“It has not been tested that Dr Dion George is underperforming,” Majola said.
“He is running a big portfolio. With his background, he is thrown into forestry and fishery. It does seem that there are some internal squabbles. They may not be happy with his performance. They are not happy that he has not shifted the needle there in terms of policy,” he said.
DA Leader and Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen has requested that President Cyril Ramaphosa sack Dion George, the Minister of Environment, Forestry and Fisheries, and replace him with party spokesperson Willie Aucamp.
George was one of six DA members appointed as ministers… pic.twitter.com/y2aAquoi2u
— Newzroom Afrika (@Newzroom405) November 8, 2025
The Southern African Faith Communities’ Environment Institute (SAFCEI) added a civil society’s perspective to the unfolding drama.
Executive Director Francesca de Gasparis, speaking to SAfm’s Bongiwe Zwane, expressed concern over the politicisation of the environment ministry.
“It’s been interesting to watch and interesting to see the politics at play,” she said.
“We have had concerns, and I’m not sure that this is necessarily going to the issues.”
Gasparis emphasized the importance of expertise and continuity in environmental leadership, especially with major global events like the G20 and climate conferences on the horizon.
“To put someone in there who doesn’t know becomes extremely obvious that they are out of their depth,” she warned.
“We’re in a real critical moment in South Africa’s history. We need strong, strong leadership in this department.”
The DA has yet to publicly clarify its rationale for the proposed replacement. Steenhuisen’s assertiveness in requesting a ministerial change may signal deeper fractures within the party or a strategic recalibration aimed at asserting control over key portfolios.
John Steenhuisen can ask the President to sack Dion George as Minister, but both Steenhuisen & Ramaphosa’s power to remove him as Commissioner from the PCC is neutered by the provisions of the Climate Change Act.
Appointed in July 2024, Dion George is a Commissioner until 2029 pic.twitter.com/hGdsqF1yUK
— Vimlesh Rajbansi (@VimleshRajbansi) November 9, 2025
1/ If Dion George is removed as Minister shouldn’t he also be removed as a commissioner from the Presidential Climate Commission?
If yes, note of the provisions in the Climate Change Act for the public process to appoint new Commissioners —The President can’t act unilaterally pic.twitter.com/JlvllMfx48
— Vimlesh Rajbansi (@VimleshRajbansi) November 9, 2025
INSIDE POLITICS
