He’s a gamer: Shedeur Sanders displaying clutch gene and fearless mentality Browns have sought for decades

CLEVELAND, Ohio — Shedeur Sanders wasn’t supposed to be here.

Not starting NFL games in December. Not leading fourth-quarter comebacks. Not showing the kind of poise, accuracy, and “it factor” that has the Cleveland Browns reconsidering their entire quarterback strategy.

But here he is, defying expectations and forcing the organization to ask a question they never anticipated: Could a fifth-round pick who slid down draft boards be the franchise quarterback they’ve been desperately searching for?

“I just think that he’s a gamer,” Browns beat reporter Mary Kay Cabot observed on the Orange and Brown Talk podcast. “I think he has established that he’s got that ‘it factor’ and that’s what you want. You want someone who has that ‘never say die’ attitude in the fourth quarter when you need to come back and try to pull out a victory.”

What’s been most surprising isn’t just Sanders’ natural talent, but his fearlessness against NFL competition. In just his third career start against the Titans, Sanders showed remarkable poise against one of the league’s most formidable defensive linemen.

“The thing that is really standing out to me is the elusiveness and the guts,” Cabot emphasized. “The guts to stand in there in the face of being about to get drilled by Jeffery Simmons or whoever else, Maxx Crosby, and stand in there and calmly deliver the pass. He’s not flinching. He’s not afraid.”

This development is particularly remarkable considering Sanders’ draft-day slide. Once projected as a potential first or second-round talent, Sanders watched as four-plus rounds passed before the Browns finally selected him. That experience, while painful, may have been the catalyst that transformed Sanders from a talented quarterback into a determined one.

“And in the final analysis, in the story of Shedeur Sanders, that might be the best thing that could have ever happened to him because he might now have the biggest chip on his shoulder that he never would have had and so much to prove, and it just may have worked in his favor tremendously,” Cabot suggested.

Sanders has never publicly acknowledged the pain of his draft-day slide, instead focusing on the present and expressing gratitude for his opportunity. But the motivation is evident in his play — the extra effort to extend plays, the willingness to take hits to complete passes and the hunger to prove himself with each snap.

Unlike his college career at Colorado, where his father Deion Sanders was the head coach, Sanders has had to truly earn his opportunity in Cleveland. Nothing was handed to him, and he was forced to work his way up from fifth-string quarterback during training camp.

His development curve has been impressively steep. In just a few weeks, Sanders has shown marked improvement in situational awareness, decision-making and pre-snap recognition. Host Dan Labbe noted that Sanders has started to understand “some of the situational stuff a little better too. Like hey you know what, throw this ball away on third down.”

Perhaps most impressive is Sanders’ natural accuracy, a trait many young quarterbacks struggle to develop. “Shedeur Sanders showed up on the doorstep with beautiful accuracy and his arm talent is exceptional in terms of throwing a catchable ball and placing it where it needs to go,” Cabot said. “He throws an incredible, incredible football and you can coach it and guys can get better at that, but he’s a natural and that’s priceless.”

As the Browns navigate their quarterback future, the intangibles Sanders is displaying — the competitive fire, the resilience, the fearlessness — might prove more valuable than any physical attribute. And they have rejection on draft day to thank for it.

Here’s the latest podcast:

Listen and subscribe to the Orange and Brown Talk podcast on Apple Podcasts and Spotify.

Football Insider newsletter free trial: Take a minute and sign up for a free trial of our Football Insider newsletter, featuring exclusive content from cleveland.com’s Browns reporters.