The future of Pittsburgh Steelers defenders Joey Porter Jr. and Keeanu Benton is uncertain as both struggle early in their third NFL season. Porter, hampered by a hamstring injury, has only played two full games, while Benton’s performance as a run defender has been disappointing. With both entering the final year of their rookie contracts after the 2025 season, the Steelers must decide on potential contract extensions. Analyst Brian Batko suggests Porter may earn a second contract despite not meeting expectations. However, he believes Benton may need to be replaced if he doesn’t show significant improvement.
By the Numbers
- Porter has allowed only nine receptions for 82 yards this season, with three pass breakups and three penalties.
- Benton struggled significantly against the run in Week 7 after showing improvement in earlier weeks.
Yes, But
While Porter has potential, his persistent penalty issues and inconsistency raise concerns about his long-term viability. Benton’s continued struggles as a run defender further complicate the decision on his future role with the team.
State of Play
- Porter returned from injury in Week 6, showing promise despite a rough Week 7 performance against Cincinnati.
- Benton’s inconsistency leaves the coaching staff considering whether he fits into their long-term plans at nose tackle.
What’s Next
As the season progresses, both players have time to turn around their performances and establish their roles. Improvement, particularly for Benton, is crucial for his future with the Steelers. Continued evaluation during the season will inform the team’s decisions on contract extensions.
Bottom Line
The Steelers face critical decisions regarding Porter and Benton, balancing their potential against current performance trends. With contract negotiations looming after the season, both players must demonstrate significant improvement to secure their futures with the team.
