Elizabeth Olsen’s Scarlet Witch: The Return Fans Crave and the Legacy of Marvel’s Boldest Moments

Quick Read

• Elizabeth Olsen remains open to reprising Scarlet Witch if the story fits.
• Olsen has expressed interest in teaming up with Aubrey Plaza’s Lady Death in future MCU projects.
• The controversial ‘A-Force’ scene in Avengers: Endgame, featuring Olsen, continues to spark debate about representation and narrative execution.
• Brie Larson and Elizabeth Olsen humorously recreated the ‘A-Force’ moment at a fan convention, reigniting discussions among fans and critics.
• As the Multiverse Saga nears its end, time may be running out for Scarlet Witch’s return.

Elizabeth Olsen’s Enduring Impact as Scarlet Witch

For many Marvel fans, Elizabeth Olsen isn’t just another actor in the sprawling superhero universe. She’s become the beating heart of one of the MCU’s most complex and beloved characters: Wanda Maximoff, better known as the Scarlet Witch. Since her dramatic exit in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, speculation about her return has been a constant buzz online and at conventions, stirring up hopes and theories that seem to multiply with each new Marvel project announcement.

Olsen herself has kept the door tantalizingly ajar. In interviews, she’s made it clear: she would step back into Wanda’s shoes, but only if the story feels right. That caveat hasn’t stopped fans from dreaming, nor has it kept Marvel from dangling possibilities, especially as the cinematic universe pivots towards more supernatural storytelling. With Aubrey Plaza’s entrance as Lady Death in Agatha All Along, the stage seems set for a new era of mystical alliances and rivalries.

The Possibility of a Scarlet Witch and Lady Death Team-Up

The idea of Olsen’s Scarlet Witch sharing screen time with Plaza’s Lady Death isn’t just a fan fantasy—it’s a concept Olsen herself has championed. Their chemistry in Ingrid Goes West left audiences wanting more, and now, with the MCU exploring the darker edges of its universe, the potential for a reunion feels more plausible than ever. Lady Death, a figure steeped in Marvel lore, could play a pivotal role in Wanda’s resurrection, should the writers choose to tread that path. Imagine Wanda, indebted to Death herself, forced to navigate a world where her powers come with new, existential strings attached.

This isn’t just about spectacle—it’s about storytelling. The Scarlet Witch’s journey has always been one of loss, redemption, and the search for belonging. Pairing her with a character who embodies the finality of death could open up rich, philosophical territory for the MCU, especially as audiences hunger for narratives that go beyond the standard hero-versus-villain template.

The Controversy and Celebration of Marvel’s Female Power Moments

Elizabeth Olsen’s influence within Marvel isn’t confined to her solo storylines. She’s been at the center of some of the franchise’s most memorable—and divisive—moments. The “A-Force” sequence from Avengers: Endgame, where female superheroes unite on the battlefield, remains a lightning rod for debate. Intended as a celebration of female empowerment, the scene was met with both applause and criticism. Some found it inspiring, a long-overdue recognition of women’s place in the superhero pantheon. Others, like The Boys creator Eric Kripke, dismissed it as “condescending and contrived,” sparking parodies and online think pieces.

Recently, Olsen and Brie Larson reignited that discussion by humorously recreating the scene at the Spaceon convention in San Antonio. Fans, cosplaying as Marvel heroes, gathered to witness the reenactment—an act that blurred the lines between homage and self-aware commentary. Paul Bettany, who plays Vision, joined in for a poignant recreation of his character’s demise, reminding everyone just how emotionally resonant these stories can be.

Marvel’s own writers, Christopher Markus and Stephen McFeely, have weighed in, defending the scene’s intent. They argued that representation matters, and that the excitement among female crew members during filming spoke volumes about the need for such moments. For many, seeing Wanda Maximoff, Captain Marvel, Okoye, Valkyrie, and others join forces wasn’t just about spectacle—it was about validation.

The Road Ahead: Will Scarlet Witch Return?

The MCU is at a crossroads. As the Multiverse Saga nears its conclusion, the window for bringing back fan favorites like Scarlet Witch is shrinking. Olsen’s willingness to return, paired with growing fan demand, creates a sense of urgency. Marvel’s next steps could define not just Wanda’s fate, but the future direction of its entire universe. Will the studio embrace the supernatural, pairing Scarlet Witch with Lady Death in a high-stakes narrative? Or will it pivot towards new heroes, leaving Wanda’s story unresolved?

These questions linger as Marvel continues to evolve. The legacy of Olsen’s Scarlet Witch—her depth, vulnerability, and power—remains a touchstone for fans. Whether she returns or not, her impact is undeniable, shaping the way audiences think about heroism, loss, and the possibility of redemption.

Elizabeth Olsen’s journey as Scarlet Witch is emblematic of Marvel’s broader struggle to balance spectacle with substance. Her story, marked by triumphs and controversies, has pushed the MCU to grapple with representation and character depth in new ways. If Marvel chooses to bring Wanda back—especially in partnership with emerging icons like Lady Death—it won’t just be a nostalgic move. It’ll be a statement about the kind of stories the MCU wants to tell, and the audiences it hopes to inspire.