If there’s one thing Brooks Nader is good at, it’s getting publicity about her dating life.
The Sports Illustrated swimsuit model turned Love Thy Nader reality star got divorced in 2024 and has been linked with a string of high-profile names in the months since.
In September, rumours circulated that she was dating two famous tennis players at the same time, Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner, during the 2025 US Open.
Appearing on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, the model, 28, finally addressed the rumours after a fan asked if the two sportsmen “knew about each other” during the tournament.
Cohen clarified the question to Nader, saying, “You were rumoured to be dating both of them at the same time,” to which Nader replied, “Right, right, I mean, I would just say, a lady never kisses and tells, especially twice. That’s just not nice”.
Her sister, Grace Ann Nader, then chimed in from the audience: “Especially not to her other boyfriend,” and Nader looked shocked and laughed.
Cohen then rephrased the question to get the interview back on track: “Did the fellas know that you were dating both of them … or were you dating both of them? Is that true?”
“I mean, dating is such a loose term these days,” Nader responded. “It’s just you know – I don’t know. By the way, my only thing is guys do it all the time. So why can’t I do it?”
Cohen emphatically replied: “Well yes they do!” before giving her a high five and a standing ovation, alongside fellow guest Mark Ronson, who also stood and clapped.
“They do it all the time!” Nader repeated.
Cohen then insisted the audience also “stand for this woman”.
“Hell yes to you … very good,” he added, clapping.
‘My idol’
Fans on social media praised the star for highlighting the double standard between men and women when it comes to dating.
“This is so iconic,” one said.
“Women in male-dominated fields,” someone else joked.
“She is my idol,” a third quipped.
Did she date both of them?
It follows Grace Ann confirming to E! News at the time that Nader was indeed seeing Spanish champion, Alcaraz, 22, during the US Open.
“The rumours are true,” she said. “He’s the man of the hour.”
Nader was then seen in the crowd as Alcaraz played French tennis pro Arthur Rinderknech.
However, Nader is also reported to have started seeing another tennis player around the same time, Alcaraz’s Italian rival, Sinner, 24, according to Page Six.
The outlet claimed she was “dating both the tennis tournament’s No. 1 and 2 seeds”.
The 28-year-old then attended the men’s singles final between Sinner and Alcaraz, which Alcaraz won.
Sinner is now dating model Laila Hasanovic and called her “my girlfriend” after winning the Vienna Open in October.
Meanwhile, Alcaraz confirmed in a recent press conference he is “free” when a journalist asked if he was single.
Nader’s dating history
Nader was previously married to advertising executive Billy Haire from 2019 until May 2024, with their divorce finalised in 2025.
The pair were together for nearly a decade after meeting in 2015 when Nader was 19 and Haire was 11 years her senior.
“I’ve been married for most of my adult life,” Nader told Page Six recently.
“So, now that I’m in my single era, I feel like I’ve come into this new version of myself and it’s so exciting and fun to discover her. The new Brooks!”
In June 2024, it was reported that she was dating Prince Constantine-Alexios of Greece.
In July of the same year, People reported that Nader and Tom Brady had been “hooking up” and having “rendezvous” in different cities.
Later in September, Nader competed as one of the celebrities on Season 33 of the US’ Dancing with the Stars and briefly dated her on-air partner, pro-dancer Gleb Savchenko.
She reportedly ended things with him after she suspected he cheated on her.
