The New York Knicks fanbase and NBA circles have recently been buzzing with trade rumors featuring Karl-Anthony Towns (KAT). The most talked-about scenario involved swapping KAT for Dallas Mavericks star Anthony Davis.
Many fans and analysts were vocal, debating the merits of such a blockbuster move. Some Knicks fans openly pushed for the trade, frustrated with what they perceived as “zero offense” from Towns at times, and arguing that “KAT for AD” would be a no-brainer, especially since both have massive, nearly identical contracts.
I don’t care what anyone says
I’m doing a KAT for AD swap without question
And their contracts are damn near identical
— Knicks Union 🗽 (@knicks_union) November 23, 2025
However, the other side of the debate stressed that Davis, while an elite defender, comes with serious injury concerns and is two years older than Towns. These critics pointed out that KAT is typically healthier, more versatile offensively, and still has room to grow with this Knicks core.
Silencing Doubters Against the Nets
Amid all the noise, Towns answered in the best way possible, with a dominant on-court performance. In the Knicks’ recent victory over the Brooklyn Nets, KAT delivered a stellar performance, scoring 37 points on an ultra-efficient 14-of-20 shooting, while adding 12 rebounds, three assists, two blocks, and a steal in just 33 minutes. This outing highlighted the skill set that made Towns a major acquisition in New York and showed why the team should not rush into any hasty trades.
It wasn’t a one-off, either. Towns has provided consistent offense all season, averaging 22.6 points and 12.4 rebounds per game, displaying a sharp shooting touch and strong work on the boards. When challenged, he elevated his play, providing the Knicks with the offensive punch and floor spacing that few centers in the league offer. This was enough to answer the negative trade talks.
Stability for the Knicks, Not Change
Head coach Mike Brown and Knicks management seem to recognize that Towns’ offensive consistency and versatility give the team a higher floor. While Anthony Davis’s defense might give a team a theoretical higher ceiling,
The Knicks are already contenders. The risk of trading for a frequently injured veteran could threaten the stability and chemistry that this roster has built around Towns and point guard Jalen Brunson.
Heartfelt Leadership
Following the win over the Nets, Towns also showed his leadership and gratitude, delivering emotional Thanksgiving comments.
“If my life’s taught me one thing, I’m thankful for the time I got with my family…this team…this City. Thankful for the opportunity to put a Knicks jersey on. To call my father & he answers. To wake up every day. And try again,” he said.
“If my life’s taught me one thing, I’m thankful for the time I got with my family…this team…this City
“Thankful for the opportunity to put a Knicks jersey on
“To call my father & he answers
“To wake up every day
“And try again”
– KAT on Thanksgiving pic.twitter.com/woukXqbuE9
— New York Basketball (@NBA_NewYork) November 25, 2025
This connection to New York and commitment to the team only strengthen his case as a cornerstone for the franchise.
Make sure you bookmark Knicks on SI for the latest news, exclusive interviews, film breakdowns and so much more!
