The Baltimore Orioles are evaluating the future of outfielder Tyler O’Neill after adding Taylor Ward to a crowded roster. Despite signing O’Neill for three years after a disappointing 2025 season filled with injuries—where he played only 54 games—there’s growing discourse on his trade potential. Current projections suggest O’Neill may struggle for consistent playing time with several outfield options available, including prospects and recently acquired players. The Orioles are weighing the cost of keeping O’Neill, especially given his inconsistent performance and declining health.
By the Numbers
- Tyler O’Neill played just 54 games in 2025, hitting .199/.292/.392 with 9 HR and 26 RBI.
- In July 2025, he hit .259/.339/.593, contributing 5 HR and 10 RBI in that month alone.
State of Play
- The Orioles’ outfield currently features eight players, raising competition for starting roles.
- Projected starters include Taylor Ward, Colton Cowser, and Dylan Beavers, limiting O’Neill’s potential playing time.
What’s Next
As the offseason progresses, the Orioles will likely assess O’Neill’s performance under newly appointed manager Craig Albernaz. If O’Neill can prove effective, particularly against left-handed pitching, he may retain his spot. Should his struggles continue into mid-2026, the team may reconsider his role or explore trade opportunities.
Bottom Line
The Orioles face a pivotal decision in determining O’Neill’s future; maintaining him risks stunting the development of younger players. If O’Neill cannot improve this season, he could become a liability rather than an asset in their postseason ambitions.
